In a perfect business world, perhaps everyone would win. But the world isn’t like that. I spent my entire working life in broadcasting, where the idea of winning was to beat out the competition. We won the day when other media outlets lost. The concept of sharing simply didn’t enter in.
For decades, that mindset was the air I breathed. Ratings came out and we either celebrated or mourned based on market share. If our ratings rose, it meant someone else’s plummeted. If our sales team secured an exclusive contract, a rival station went hungry. It was a relentless cycle driven by scarcity and the belief that we needed to claim the largest slice of the pie, no matter who left the table empty-handed.
Yet, as the years rolled on and my faith deepened, a quiet dissonance began to take root. How does a Christian reconcile the cutthroat demands of modern industry with the Gospel’s call to love our neighbor, practice solidarity, and seek the common good? Can a marketplace driven purely by rivalry align with a Catholic worldview?
The Illusion of the Finite Pie
The secular marketplace teaches us that resources, attention, and market share are strictly limited. It creates a mindset of fear that another person's rise inevitably causes our fall. But Catholic social teaching offers a radically different view. It reminds us that work is not merely an arena for dominance, but a participation in God’s ongoing creation.
When we view business purely through the paradigm of defeat, we reduce human ingenuity and partnership to mere leverage. In broadcasting, we measured victory in quarterly ad revenue and Nielsen points. Perhaps as individuals we paused to ask deeper questions: Are we serving the truth? Are we building up our community? Are we uplifting the human spirit? But those questions did not drive the bottom line.
A Higher Standard of Victory
It’s important to note that integrating Catholic values into professional life does not mean abandoning excellence or ignoring commercial realities. Profitability is essential; it sustains enterprises, compensates employees fairly, and supports families. However, faith also challenges us to redefine what "winning" actually means.
Ad: Discover the place where Our Lady of Guadalupe appeared to St. Juan Diego. See her image. And join Archbishop José Gómez, Bishop Thomas Olmsted and Bishop Timothy Freyer for The Hour of the Laity 2026 in Mexico City.
True Christian leadership moves beyond zero-sum ambition toward a culture of stewardship. It asks us to look at competitors not as enemies to be vanquished but as fellow actors in a broader ecosystem. It invites us to consider ethical integrity, fair labor practices, and client well-being as core components of success.
Imagine a professional landscape where success is measured not by who was defeated, but by how much value was created, how many lives were dignified, and how faithfully we used our God-given talents. What if broadcasting… or finance, technology, or healthcare… focused as much on enriching the common good as on capturing market share?
Living the Shift Today
Transitioning from a mindset of ruthless competition to kingdom-minded stewardship is no easy task. It requires intentionality and courage, especially in high-stakes environments. It begins with small, daily decisions: refusing to engage in deceptive practices, mentoring younger colleagues, giving credit where it is due, and treating industry peers with genuine charity.
Looking back on my years in broadcasting, I realize that the ratings victories eventually faded. What remains, and what truly matters, are the relationships I built, and the quiet ways God’s grace transformed my perspective on work. In God’s kingdom, victory isn't achieved by pushing others down; it is found in lifting each other up.
P.S. Join Archbishop José Gómez, Bishop Thomas Olmsted and Bishop Timothy Freyer for The Hour of the Laity 2026 in Mexico City. In the videos bellow you will see what they have to say about THL2026.
Ad: Tepeyac Leadership’s Leadership for the World is a $2 million, three year mission to form lay Catholic leaders for the public square. Without formation, others fill the void. Will you step in or step aside now, when it matters most?
